XXIV. ISOCRATES
1. Di怷nys. Hal. de Isocr. p. 55, 10 Us.-R.: 庰弮峟彖庢彖 庰 帢帢弇帢帣廔樁 廔棒 廒庥庢庣彖 彃僇 弇帠彖 廔廔 彃僇 庰廔 怷帠巹帢彖 庥帢廔 帢帠帢彖 怷庣彃僇 彃剿怷 廒庢庰彖 廒廔 彃僇 廒庣庣庥彃僇 庰 庥帢廔 庣庥彃僇 廒廔 怷廔磁 怷弇庣庣庥怷廔磁 庥帢廔 庰廔 帢廔廔棒 怷帤峎庤彖 廔棒 廒庣峸弮庢彖 帤庣庰峟弇庰庰彖, 廒徆 廒彷, 廔甩 庢庣彖 帢廔, 廔 帣怷弇庰庰庛帢庣 庥帢廔 弇峟帠庰庣彖 庥帢廔 峎庰庣彖 廔 弮峟怷彖帢 帢帢帠巹彖庰帢庣 怷彃 弮帢庛怷彃羊庣彖.
Cf. Isocr. ep. 5, 4, 怷r. 15, 175. 255. 276.
2. [Plut.] vitae 峓 orr. 837 b: 廔﹡樁翁銜舒 帤廔 怷彃 帣怷弇怷弮峟彖怷庣, 巹帢 彃剿怷 怷廔磁 廒庣庣庥怷廔磁 弇帠怷 彃僇 怷弇庣庣庥彃僇, 庰廔 怷廔 廒怷帤帢庰.
3. Philod. rhet. II 122, 11 S.: 廔 帤庰 廒裒怷庥峎庢[ 庥帢廔跑 峟彖帢 庥帢帢弇[庣弮庰]彖[怷] 廒弇弇怷庣 庰 怷弇[弇怷廔 怷]庣帢廔 [庛帢]弮帢廔廂彖 帢廔]廔棒 庰廒僇諄敖 [峟]彖庢彖 [廒怷帢]巹彖怷彖帢庣.
Cf. Di怷nys. Hal. ad Ammaeum p. 259, 2 Us.-R. (supra XXII 3).
4. Quint. inst. 3, 1, 14: postmeridianis scholis Aristoteles praecipere artem oratoriam coepit, noto quidem illo, ut traditur, versu ex Philocteta frequenter usus: turpe esse tacere et Is怷craten pati dicere. ars est utriusque.
5. Plut. Demosthenes c. 5, 7: 庢庣帣巹怷 帤廔 弮峟弮彖庢帢庣 (scil. Hermippus) 弇峟帠怷彖怷 帢廔 帢弇弇巹怷 怷彃 峉帢庥怷巹怷 庥帢巹 庣彖彖 廒弇弇彖 廔區 廒裒怷庥峎怷 峟彖帢 庥帢廔 廔區 廒弇庥庣帤峎弮帢彖怷 庥帢 弇帢帣彖帢 廔裕 庢弮怷庛峟彖庢彖 庥帢帢弮帢庛庰彃彖.
Huic fabulae nihil subesse potest nisi quod 彃僇 廒庰庣庥彃僇 帤庣帤帢帠弮峎彖 Isocratis artem fuisse creditum est. 弇帠彖 峟彖帢 廒帢帠帠峟弇弇庰庛帢庣 Alcidamas socratis esse dicit 庰廔 怷庣彃僇 15, quod ad scriptam artem non pertinet. Vide seq.
6. Diog. Laert. IV 1, 2: 庥帢廔 彃剿怷 (scil. Speusippus) 帢廔 廒裒怷庥峎怷 廔 庥帢弇怷弮庰彖帢 廒庢帢 廒徆峸彖庰帠庥庰彖, 廔甩 庢庣 帢庣彖庰.
7. Cic. inv. 2, 2, 7: nam fuit tempore eodem, quo Arist怷teles, magnus et nobilis rhetor Isocrates. cuius ipsius quam constet esse artem, non invenimus, discipulorum autem atque eorum, qui protinus ab hac sunt disciplina profecti, multa de arte praecepta reperimus.
Cf. A V 9 sq. Philod. rhet. I 147 Col. II S.: (彖怷弮巹庤怷庣) 弮庢帤宎 廒彖 怷 庥帢廔 庣弇怷怷巹帢彖 廔棒 廒帢彃僇 帤[彖帢弮庣彖 庥]帢廔 峟彖庢彖 [庰廒僇諄敖. 庰]廒 帤宎 廒帣怷廔銜銜諺誕怷 [弮廔統 峟]彖[庢彖 庰廒僇諄敖,] 廔棒 帤宎 帢廔廔棒 [怷廔帢]彖 廒 弮彖庢彖 廒 弮峎弇庣宎 廒彖 峸[庰庣, 彖]彖弮 彃 [彃僇 廒裒怷庥]帢庣庥彃僇 庥帢廔 彃跋彖 廔弮怷巹]彖 廒庥峎弇怷彖. 廒裒怷庥峎庰庣怷庣 vel 怷廒 廒宎 廒裒怷庥峎怷 alibi audiunt. Ad rem inlustrandam utile est, quod apud Philod. rhet. II 252, 28 nominantur oratores [彖峎徆庰庣 怷廔]庥 廒怷彖[庰 廒廔 彃僇 帤庣帤帢]庥帢弇庰巹彖 [庰怷弮]峟彖帢 庥帢廔 帢[帢帤庣帤怷弮峟彖]帢, si fides est supplementis.
8. Cic. Att. 2, 1, 1: quamquam tua illa legi enim libenter horridula mihi atque incompta visa sunt, sed tamen erant ornata hoc ipso, quod ornamenta neglexerant, et, ut mulieres ideo bene olere, quia nihil olebant, videbantur. meus autem liber totum Isocrati 弮怷庛峸庥庣怷彖 atque omnes eius discipulorum arculas ac non nihil etiam Aristotelia pigmenta consumpsit (scil. commentarius consulatus).
9. [Plut.] Vitae X orr., Isocr. 838 e/f: 庰廒區廔 帤宎 怷廒 庥帢廔 峟彖帢 帢廔廔裕 弇峟帠怷庣 帠帠庰帠帢峟彖帢庣, 怷廒 帤宎 怷廔 弮庰庛帤彃 廒弇弇宎 廒庥峸庰庣 峸帢庛帢庣.
10. Photius Bibl. p. 486 b 7 Bkk.: 帠庰帠帢峟彖帢庣 帤廔 帢廔廔裕 庥帢廔 峟彖庢彖 彃用煙怷庣庥廔棒 弇峟帠怷庣彖, 廒彖 庥帢廔 廒﹡樁菲 廒棲弮庰彖 怷彃 廒彖帤廔裒 廒庣帠帢怷弮峟彖庢彖 彃 廔彖弮帢庣. 怷廒 帤廔 彖帢庥峸庰庣 弮彄僇銜銜諺 廒 峟彖彃 峸帢庛帢庣 庥帢廔 怷廔磁 弇帠怷 廔裕 廒彖帤帢 帢巹.
11. Vita Isocr. XII (Or. Att. II 5a 37, Rose, Aristotelis fr. 141): 弇峟帠庰帢庣 帤廔 廔＋ 廔庣 庥帢廔 峟彖庢彖 彃用煙怷庣庥廔棒 廒帠帢庰, 彃 帤廔 彖彃 廒庰彖 帢廔廔棒 廒怷弇峟庛帢庣. 廒庰彃 帤峟 庣繚 庥帢廔 庛庰彖 帤彃弇怷彖, 廔庣 怷彃羊怷 怷廔 廒庰庣; 弇峟帠怷弮庰彖 廔＋ 廔庣 廒庣怷峟弇庢 廔 庣弇怷怷 彖帢帠帢帠廔樁 峟彖帢 彃用煙怷庣庥廔區 廒弮彖峸庛庢 庥帢廔 帢庢.
12. Excerpta Corporis P, W II p. 683, 19 = P.S. p.60, 4 R.: 怷帠巹帢... 庥帢廔 廒裒怷庥峎庢 廒帠帢帢彖 峟彖庢彖 (峟彖帢 emend. Rabe).
13. Sopater in Hermog. W V p. 7, 12: 弮庰宎 帢廔廔裕 廒彖庣彃僇 廔 彃疥敖樁諄諫庣怷 廔 怷庥帤巹帤怷 帤庣帤峎庥帢弇怷 弇峟帠庰帢庣 峟彖庢彖 帠峎帢庣, 弮庰廔 帢彃羊帢 帤廔 廒裒怷庥峎庢 廔 彃用晅. 庥帢廔 彄剿帢庣 弮廔統 帢廔帢庣 帤庢弮帢帠帠庣庥帢廔 峟彖帢庣 庰廒區巹彖.
De Sopatr怷 v. supra p. 76.
14. Cic. Brut. 12, 48: Isocratem primo artem dicendi esse negavisse (ait Aristoteles), scribere autem aliis solitum orations sed cum saepe ipse in iudicium vocaretur, orations aliis destitisse scribere totumque se ad artes componendas transtulisse.
Vide plena verba supra A V 9. Artes, Graece 峟彖帢庣, hic orationes esse ad regulam expolitae videntur.
15. Epistolae Socraticorum (Speusippi) XXX 4 (廒裒怷庥峎庢彖) 廔裕 廒彖 帢彃 峟彖帢庣 廒怷帢庣彖弮庰彖怷彖 廒庥 彃 炟廒庣彖 帠怷彖怷彖 廒 怷廔磁 庰廔彖怷 帤庰彃彖 怷庰彃彖帢庣 怷廔磁 廒庥怷帢峎.
Fort. 廒庥 彃 <庰廔弇怷帠巹>帢 彃僇 怷帠彖彖 庰廔彖怷 帤庰彃彖 怷庰彃彖 怷廔磁 廒庥怷帢峎 deleta ante 庰廔彖怷 dittographia 廒 怷廔磁. Ceterum ad Is. 5, 77 verba referunt.
16. Ibid. XXX 10: 庥帢巹 庢庣 弮廔統 廒彖 帢彃 峟彖帢庣 怷峸庥庰庣彖 怷廒匿睡菲帢 庥帢廔 帠彖庣弮帢 廔 帢帢帤庰巹帠弮帢帢 峟庰庣彖, 廔弇庣帠峸帢 帤廔 彃 峟彖庢 廒弇弇怷巹怷庣 庥帢廔 怷彃 帢廒區巹怷庣 庥帢廔 怷彃 廔裒 廔裕 弇帠怷彖 廔＋ 廒彖帢彖庣峎怷庣 帢帢帤庰巹帠弮帢庣 彃帢庣.
Haec pertinere videntur ad Euagorae 12 sq. et 77, unde tales orationes 峟彖帢 esse dictas sequitur. Artem ab Isocrate scriptam esse vix demonstrant.
17. [Plut.] Vitae X 怷rr. 837a de Isocrate: 庥帢廔 廒庥庰巹彖怷 (Theramenis) 庣彖廔區 怷廔帢 峟彖帢 帢廔彃 帢庣 弮帢帠弮帢庰帢庛帢庣 帢廒 庰廒區庣彖 廒庣帠庰帠帢弮弮峟彖帢庣 彖怷.
18. Quint. inst. 2, 15, 4 (Sheehan 1): haec opinio (rhet怷ricen esse 帤彖帢弮庣彖) originem ab socrate, si tamen re vera ars quae circumfertur eius est, duxit, qui, cum longe sit a voluntate infamantium oratoris officia, finem artis temere comprendit dicens esse rhetoricen persuadendi opificem, id est 庰庣庛怷彃羊 帤庢弮庣怷帠彖.
Ibid. 33: quidam etiam philosophiae (partem rhetoricen vocant), quorum est Isocrates. Haec ex orationibus conclusio facile duci potuit. Ad 庰庣庛怷彃羊 帤庢弮庣怷帠彖 Antid. 249, 275, 276 sq., confert alia Sheehan p. 12, plurima Pantatzes I p. 23 sq.
19. Sextus Emp. adv. math. II 62: 廒裒怷庥峎庢 庢廔 弮庢帤廔統 廒弇弇怷 廒庣庢帤庰庰庣彖 怷廔磁 彃用晅怷帢 廒 廒庣峸弮庢彖 庰庣庛怷彃羊.
Thiele, Herm. 27, 12.
20. Philod. (pugnans. cum rhetoricis sophistis) rhet. I 212, 19 S.: 彖彃缶 帤廔 庥廒庥庰彃彖帢 帤庣帢弇庢峟怷彖 帢廔彃僇, 廔庣 彃僇 弮廔統 怷帣弇庢弮峎彖 廔 弮廔統 廒廔僇 帤庣庥帢彖庣庥峎, 廔 帤廔 弮帣怷弇庰庣庥峎, 廔 帤廔 庰廔 怷廔磁 廒帢巹彖怷 庥帢廔 帠怷, 廔形 廔 弮廔統 彖峟庰庣彖 廒帢帢彖 廔區 廔裒 廒弇弇峸弇怷 廒庣弇怷庥峎, 廔 帤宎 廔怷帠峎庰庣彖 廔 弮峟怷彖帢 彄剿庣彖, 廔 帤宎 廒廔 廔區 廒庰廔區 怷峟庰庣彖 庥帢廔 彃僇 庥帢庥庣彃僇 廒帢弇弇峎庰庣彖.
Isocratis 怷弇庣庣庥廔棒 庣弇怷怷巹帢彖 spectare videntur, v. e. g. 2, 8. 3, 1 sq. 5, 17. 8, 39. 9, 5. 12, 246. 271. 15, 255.
21. Ioannes Sardianus in Aphthonii Prog. p. 126, 19 R. (de encomio. Sh. 9): 廔裕 弇峟帠怷彖帢 帤庰彃 庥帢廔 廔裕 廒裒怷庥峎庢彖 弮帢彖庛峎彖庰庣彖 弮廔統 廔區 帤庣帢庣峟庰庣, 庥庣廔棒 帤廔 庰廒僇諄敖 彃 峸庰 庥帢廔 弮帣帢巹彖怷彖帢 庥帢庣怷彃 庥帢廔 怷怷庣 庥帢廔 峎帠弮帢庣 怷庣庰彃庛帢庣 怷廔磁 弇帠怷.
Eadem habent Scholia in Aphth. Parisina (ex Nicolai Sophistae Prog. cf. Rhet. gr. XI ed. Felten p. 58) W II 632, 25 sq. (3 彃 庥巹庰 Scholia W, 4 庥帢廔 庥帢庣怷彃 Nic.)
22. Syrianus in Herm怷g. I, p. 28, 6 R. (cf. 30, 14. 32, 1. 67, 10) et Maximus Planudes in Hermog. W V, p. 469, 6 (Sh. 7): 廒庥 彃 廒裒怷庥峎怷 峟彖庢 帤庣帤帢庥弮庰庛帢, 怷彃帢庣 彃僇 弇峟徆庰彖 弇峟帠怷彖帢庣 庥帢庛帢帢巹 怷怷彃羊怷彖 帠廔區 庰彖庣庥庰 彃 庥帢庛帢庢怷 廔 廒彖峸, 廔＋ 5 庥帢廔 廒彖 彃 怷廒匿睡舒脊噫 峟彖彃 怷庣峎帤庰 帢帢帠帠峟弇弇庰庣彖 庰廔 弇峟徆庰繚 帤庰彃 帤廔 彃 弮廔統 弇峟徆庰庣 廔 彖峸彖庰彖帢 弮廔 弮巹庰庣彖 (弇廔裕 帠廔區 廔 怷庣彖帤庰), 弮庢帤廔 庰弇庰彄僇 庥帢廔 廒庰庛帢庣 廒廔 彃 帢廔彃 弇弇帢帣彃, 怷廒煎諺 庰廒區怷彃羊帢 帢彃, 廒﹡銜翁睡 庥帢弇峎, 廒彖庛帢 帢弇彃, 庥帢廔 怷廔磁 彖帤峟弮怷 怷廔磁 帢廔怷廔磁 弮廔 彖庰帠帠 庣庛峟彖帢庣 庥帢廔 廔裕 廒弮庰彖怷彖 彃 廒﹡割諫弮峟彖彃 庰廔庛廔磁 廒彖帢怷帤庣帤彖帢庣, 廔彖弮帢庣 帤廔 彃庛帢庣 {廒 弮庰帢怷彄榔 廒 彃 庥帢弇弇巹彃 廒 彃
4 De 庥帢庛帢 vocabuli sensu v. Peters p. 57, 5.
Eadem paullo uberius Ioannes Siceliota reddit W VI 156, 16 sq., ipsum se laudat Maximus l. l. p. 473, 6. 3 廒庥 彃 - 庥帢庛帢帢巹 om. Sy 5 帤庰彃 帤廔 Sy 6 彖庰弮巹庰庣彖 Max 7 怷廒煎諺 om. Max 廔＋ 廔 Io 8 彖帤峟弮怷 帢廔怷廔磁 Max 9. 10 post 庰廔庛廔磁 廒彖帢怷帤庣帤彖帢庣 Io addit: 怷廔磁 弮峟彖宎, 廔＋ 廔 帢彃羊帢 弮廔統 怷庣帢彃羊帢, 廒庥庰彃彖帢 弮峟彖怷庣 廒峟, 怷廔磁 帤峟宎, 廔＋ 廔裕 弮廔統褊 庥帢廔 廔裕 帤峟. 庥帢廔 廔 廔＋宎 庥帢廔 廔 怷廔宎 10 廒 弮庰帢怷彄 弮廔 庥弇庢彄 廒 彃 庥帢弇弇. Io
Cf. Dionys. Hal. de Is. p. 57, 9 Us.-R., Anaximenes 2 p. 63, 1 H.: 廔 彖峸庰彖帢 帤廔 弮廔 巹庛庰庣 帢宎 廒弇弇庢弇帢, 廒彖 弮峸 怷庰 廒弇弇 廒帤彖帢怷彖 彄 帤庢弇彃剿帢庣 廒 廒彖峎徆庣 彄 庣 廒 廒弇弇庢 帤庣帢巹庰庣. Cf. ibid. p. 61, 24. Hinc Cicero Brut. 8,32:
廒用睡圖帢 庰怷庣庢弮峟彖彃 廒 彃 帠彖庣弮峎彃. 廔弇 帤廔 廔 弇帠怷 弮廔 弇帠怷 廒 (徆庢廔裕 帠峎), 廒弇弇廔 弮庰弮巹庛 帢彖廔 彃甩庛弮彃, 弮峎弇庣帢 <廒匿敖樁統團筵蕙 廒 怷帢庥彃>繚 帤庣庢帠庢峟怷彖 帤廔 廔 彃剿怷彖 庥帢廔 廔 帤庰庰怷彖 庥帢廔 廔 弇怷庣廔 廒怷弮峟彖 庥帢廔 弮峸, 廔僇 廒怷庰弇峟帢庣 廔 彃剿怷彖, 廒宎 廒弇弇o 廒匿倀諄敖, 5 庰廒剿帢 廒廔 廔 彃剿怷彖 廒帢彖庣峟彖帢庣 廒廔 怷彃 峟弇怷.
1 post 庰怷庣庢弮峟彖彃 Io addit 廔＋ 廔 巹庤庰庣彖 庥帢廔 帤怷彃羊怷繚 帢彃羊帢 帠廔區 庰怷庣庢弮峟彖帢 廒反怷庣 彃 帠彖庣弮峎彃 Io 廔弇怷 Syriani Marcianus hic et p. 32, 2 R., item Sy p. 30, 15 R. p. 67, 11, Ioannis Parisinus, An怷nymus W VII 963, 21, 廔弇 Io etiam p. 165, 30 Anonym. W VII 1046, 21 2 彃甩庛弮彃, 弮峎弇庣帢 廒匿敖樁統團筵蕙 廒 怷帢庥彃 Anon. Schol. W VII 934, 1, 廒匿敖樁裕團筵蕙 廒 怷帢庥彃 omittunt reliqui testes, item Anonymus ipse p. 1046, 23, 廒匿敖樁統團筵蕙 弮峎弇庣帢 廒 怷帢庥彃 Ioannes Sic. p. 166, 2 5 庰廒剿帢 峎弇庣彖 廒廔 廔 彃剿怷彖 廒帢彖庣峟彖帢庣, 庥帢廔 帢廒 廒廔 弮峟怷 帤廔 帤庣峎彖怷庣帢庣 庰弇庰庣怷庛帢彖 廒宎 廒帢廔區 庰庣帠帢弮庰彖帢庣. 帢彃羊帢 庰廔 庥帢庛帢庢怷 廒裒怷庥峎庢 Io p. 157, 5
exstitit Isocrates is et ipse scripsit multa praeclare et docuit alios, et cum cetera melius quam superiores, tum primus intellexit etiam insoluta oratione, dum versum effugeres, modum tamen et numerum quendam oportere servari. Cf. Or. 52, 175 sq. Aristot. rhet. 1408 b 21 廔 帤廔 彃弮帢 彃 弇峟徆庰 帤庰彃 弮峸庰 廒弮弮庰怷彖 庰廒僇諄敖 弮峸庰 廒庛弮怷彖. Cic. Orat. 57, 195: nec numerosa esse, ut poema, neque extra numerum, ut sermo vulgi, esse debet oratio. Cf. De orat. 3, 44, 175. Dionys. Hal. de comp. verb. p. 124, 21 sq. Us.-R., Quintil. inst. 9, 4, 45 sq. p. 158, 4: Sic etiam Anaximenes 30, p. 72, 9. 38, p. 100, 12 H. Cf. Peters p. 58. Isocratis praecepta Philodemus spectare videtur, cum dicit rhet. I p. 160, 11 S.: 廔裒 帤廔 怷怷庣, 廒 庥帢廔 帢峎 庣庣 彃僇 庰彖怷帠峎彖 庥帢帢庥庰庣帢庣, 帤庣廔 廔 庥帢帢庥彖怷彃缶 怷彃 廔庰帣峎怷庣, 怷廔庥 怷廔庢 廒彖峎帠庥庢, 庢庣弮庰庰庣彖 廔怷弇帢弮帣峎彖怷彖帢, 廒彖 帤廔 廒彖帢帠庥帢彃怷彖 彄 彃庛帢庣, 弮廔 帣帢帢怷彖 廔＋ 弮峎弇庣帢 怷廔[弮 弮峟彃設 怷庣庰彃彖 庥帢廔 廔稟彖 ]彖帤庰[弮怷彖 弮廔弼 帤庣廔 [帣帢峟]彖 廒彖帢怷[帤庣]帤彖帢庣 ...... (p. 161, 6) [彃僇 ]峎[庰彖] 帢彃 [庥帢]庛弮庣[弇庢弮峟]彖帢庣 彃庛帢庣 弮庰廔 怷彃 峟怷彖怷 庥帢廔 弮峸宎 廒庥 弮峸庰 庥帢庛怷弇庣庥彃剿 弮峸庰 庥怷庣彖彃剿 廒弇弇廔 彃用煙彃剿 廒庥峟庰庣彖. Cf. seq. et Philod. I p. 185, 16 sq. S., ubi l. 22 sq. 怷廔磁 帤 廒帢庥怷[弇怷庛怷彃缶稽帢 彖帤庰弮怷[ 廒彖帢怷]帤庣帤彖帢庣 supplendum videtur. Cf. infra 24. Isocr. 12, 24.
23. Maximus Planudes W V 497, 26 (Sh. 18): 怷廒 廒庣庥庣帢廔 帢彖庰弇彃剿 廒怷峟怷庣 怷彃 廔彖怷弮帢怷怷庣庰彃彖 庥帢廔 弮彖怷庣 怷峎怷庣 庥庰彃庛帢庣 帢彃 庰廒區庢弮峟彖帢庣 弇峟徆庰庣 庥帢廔 怷彃 庰帢帠弮峟彖怷庣 廔彖弮帢庣彖, 廔甩 庢庣彖 廒裒怷庥峎庢.
Cf. Euagorae (9) 10
24. Aristot. rhet. 1407 a 30: 廒彖 弮廔統 帤廔 廔 庰廔 廒彖 怷彃 彖帤峟弮怷庣, 帤庰庰怷彖 帤廔 廔 怷彃 廒匿棒翁諺圖 廔彖弮帢庣 弇峟帠庰庣彖 庥帢廔 弮廔 怷彃 庰庣峟怷庣彖.
Observabis eundem esse praeceptorum ordinem, qui auctore Syriano est apud Isocratem. Inverso ordine Anaximenes 25, p. 61, 23 彃剿怷彖 弮廔統 怷廔彖 廔彖弮帢庤庰 怷彃 怷廒匿睡舒翁諺圖 廔彖弮帢庣彖, deinde 庰廔 彖帤峟弮彖 agit. Ceterum etiam tria quae secuntur Aristotelis praecepta 廔 弮廔 廒弮庣帣弇怷庣 彃庛帢庣, 廔 廔 帠峟彖庢 彃僇 廔彖怷弮峎彖 帤庣帢庣庰彃彖, 廔 廔 怷弇弇廔 庥帢廔 廔弇巹帠帢 庥帢廔 廒彖 廔庛彃剿 廔彖怷弮峎庤庰庣彖 ex antiquiorum, imprimis Isocrateorum artibus delibata esse pr怷babile videtur; ad rem cf. Wendland p. 44 sq., Peters 58.
25. Aristot. rhet. 1407 a 19: 廒庣 帤宎 廒廔 彃 弇峟徆庰 廔 廒弇弇庢彖巹庤庰庣彖. 怷彃羊怷 帤宎 廒庣彖 廒彖 峟彖庰, 彃剿怷彖 弮廔統 廒彖 怷彃 彖帤峟弮怷庣, 廒彖 廒怷帤庣帤彃 庣 廔＋ 庰庥帢庣 庰怷庣 庥帢廔 廔庰怷庣 帠巹帠彖庰庛帢庣 廒弇弇峸弇彖, 怷廒煎諺 廒彖庣怷庣 廒帢庣怷彃羊庣彖, 廔甩庰 廔 弮廔統褊 庥帢廔 廔 廒帠廔 弮廔統褊 廒帢庣庰彃 廔裕 帤廔粗 庥帢廔 廔裕 廔 帤峟. 帤庰彃 帤廔 廒 弮峟弮彖庢帢庣 廒彖帢怷帤庣帤彖帢庣 廒弇弇峸弇怷庣 庥帢廔 弮峸庰 弮帢庥廔匿 廒帢彄僇 弮峸庰 彖帤庰弮怷彖 廔 彖帤峟弮怷 廒怷帤庣帤彖帢庣 怷彃 廒彖帢帠庥帢巹怷繚 廔弇庣帠帢怷彃 帠廔區 廒弮庰庣.
Cf. Anaximenes 25 p. 62, 5 H.: 弮庰廔 帤廔 彖帤峟弮怷 怷廔 廒彖 怷庰巹彃, 廒怷帤巹帤怷 怷廔磁 廒庥怷弇怷庛怷彃缶誕帢. 廔 弮廔統 怷廔彖 怷廔磁 彖帤峟弮怷 廒怷帤庣帤彖帢庣 怷廔磁 廒庥怷弇怷庛怷彃缶誕帢 怷庣彖帤庰 廒巹彖繚 廒帠廔 弮廔統 庥弇. At Demetrius de eloc. 53 (genus dicendi magnificum tractans): 廔 帤廔 庥帢廔 怷廔磁 彖帤峟弮怷 弮廔 弮峎弇帢 廒彖帢怷帤巹帤怷庛帢庣 廒庥庣帣彃剿, 怷廒煎諺 彃 弮廔統褊 彖帤峟弮彃 廔裕 帤峟, 弮庣庥怷庰廔紮 帠廔區 廒 廒庥巹帣庰庣帢 庥弇. Cf. ibid. 58: 怷廒 帤廔 廔裒 怷廔帤廔統 廒彖帢弇庢怷彃缶誕庰, 庢巹, 廔裕 彖帤庰弮怷彖 廒怷巹庥帢庣 怷彃 廔怷庥庣帢彃 怷彃 廔 庥帢廔 廔 廔裒 怷廔帤廔統 廒怷 弇峟帠怷庣彖 (庢廔 scil. Praxiphanes). Auctor de subl. 21: 峟庰 怷廔彖, 庛庰 怷廔磁 彖帤峟弮怷, 庰廒 庛峟弇怷庣, 廔＋ 怷庣怷彃羊庣彖 怷廒 廒裒怷庥峎庰庣怷庣. Epicurus apud Philod. rhet. II 259, 28 S.: 帢彃羊峎 庰 帤廔 帢廔怷彃 庰巹庰庣彖 廒庥 怷彃 峎帠弮帢怷 庥帢廔 廒弮帢 彖帤峟弮怷庣 廒庰庛帢庣 怷庰彃剿 庥帢廔 庰庣彖 廒彖 怷彃 弇庰帠怷弮峟彖怷庣.
26. Menander 庰廔 廒庣帤. Rhet. gr. III, p. 339, 11 Sp. (Sh. 10): 廒 帤廔 廒弮庢彖庰巹帢... 廒廔 廒弇峎怷彖怷 廒徆怷巹帢 帠庰帠庰彖峸庛, 彃棒僇諫帢 弮廔統 廔裕 廒庣帤庰庣庥庣庥廔裕 庥弮怷彖, 怷弇廔 帤廔 怷彃 帤庣庛峎弮帣怷 廒怷帣庰帣庢庥彃帢. 帠巹帠彖怷庣怷 帤宎 <廒彖> 怷庣帢庢, 庰廒 彃 廒裒怷庥峎怷 庛庰峸弮帢庣 庢弮庰庛帢 庥帢廔 廔 庥峎弇弇怷 庥帢廔 廔棒 庰弮彖庢帢 弮廔 廒廔 彃僇 廔彖怷弮峎彖 弮彄僇銜銜諺 廒 彃 廒帢庣庢怷 廒 怷彃 弮庰帠峟庛怷 庛庢弮庰庛帢, 廒弇弇宎 廒廔 彃 廒弮怷彖巹帢 庥帢廔 彃僇 庢弮峎彖.
27. Longini artis rhet. I, p. 306, 8 Sp., 188, 21 H. (Sh. 11): 怷廔庥 廒庰彃怷彖 帤廔 怷廔帤廔 彃僇 廒裒怷庥峎怷 帢帢帠帠庰弇弮峎彖 廒彖峟庰庛帢庣, 弮廔 帢彖庰庣彖 廔裕 弇帠怷彖 彃 帢帢庛峟庰庣 庥帢廔 弮弇怷庥彃 彃僇 庥帢弇怷弮峟彖彖 彖庢峟彖彖.
Cf. Ioannes Sic. W VI 102, 22 sq. Dion. Hal. de Isocr. p. 57, 9 Us.-R.
28. Schol. in Hermog. W VII, p. 930, 11 (Sh. 17) de c怷l怷 et commate: 廒弇弇廔 彃剿怷彖 弮廔統 廒怷巹庥帢庣彖 彃僇 廔彖怷弮峎彖 怷彖 廒弇庛庰彃彖 庰廒區 廒彖彖怷庣帢彖 廒彖 廒徆庰峎庰庣 弇帠彖 怷廔 庥帢廔 弮峟帢 o庰彖庢彖庰帠弮峟彖彖 庣弇o彖 弮廔統 廒庣怷峟弇庢 廒彖 帢彃 彃用煙怷庣庥帢彃 弇庰帠怷弮峟彖帢庣 峟彖帢庣, 怷庣彃僇 帤廔 廒裒怷庥峎庢. 巹 帤廔 怷彖 廒庥帢怷 弇峟帠庰庣 庥帢廔 廔 弮廔統 廒庣怷峟弇庢 廔棒 庰巹怷帤怷彖 廔＋巹帢怷, 廔＋ 弮弇庢怷彃 廔 庥彃僇銜 庥帢廔 廔 庥弮弮帢帢, 廔 帤廔 峎弇庣彖 廒裒怷庥峎庢, 彃 帢峎彃 帤庰彖 廒彖 彃 庰廔 帢廔彃僇 庰廒棲庢帢庣 弇帠彃麻 怷弇弇怷廔磁 帠廔區 廔庣弮怷廔磁 彃僇 廒帢巹彖 帢帢巹庛庢庣. 弇峟帠庰庣 帠廔區 庥帢廔 廒裒怷庥峎怷 廔庣弮彖, 廔彖 怷廔 帢帢帤峟庰帢庣繚 彃 帠廔區 廒庣怷峟弇庰庣 怷廔帤庰弮巹帢 帠峟帠怷彖庰 庰廔 帢廔怷彃 怷帤峸.
En gravissimum testimonium, quod docet iam Isocratem 廒彖 廒徆庰峎庰庣 弇帠彖 怷廔 庥帢廔 弮峟帢 o庰彖庢彖庰帠弮峟彖彖 nominibus commatis, coli, perihodi esse usum. Ex quo sequitur, eos quoque, qui 怷庣峸弮帢帢 recensebant, perihodi nomen adhibuisse. Cf. Longinus art. rhet. p. 193, 28 H.: 廒 庰巹怷帤怷 庥峟庥弇庢帢庣 廒庥 弮庰帢怷彄剿 廒廔 彃僇 怷庰彖彖 庰廔 怷廔磁 帣弮怷, quod si verum, 庰巹怷帤怷彖 et 怷峸彖 idem signiicasse apparet.
29. Dion. Hal. de Lysia 16/17 sq. p. 27, 12 Us.-R. (Sh. 4): 帤庣帢庣峸怷弮帢庣 廔＋ 廒裒怷庥峎庰庣 庰 庥帢廔 怷彃 庥帢宎 廒庥庰彃彖怷彖 廔裕 廒彖帤帢 庥怷弮怷弮峟彖怷庣 廒反庰庰彖, 廒徆峎弮庰彖怷 廒廔 彃僇 怷怷庣弮巹彖. (p. 28, 13 sq.) 帢彃羊帢... 庰庣弇帢帣廔樁 廒廔 廔棒 庛庰庣彖 廒庰巹帠庰帢庣, 帤庣宎 廒彷 廔 弮峟弇弇怷彖帢 廒彖 帢彃 廒怷帤庰巹徆庰庣 弇峟帠庰庛帢庣 怷庰庣廔樁 庥帢廔 廔裕 廒庥怷帢廔棒 帢帢庥庰峎帢 庰廔弮帢庛彃 廔裒 廔裕 弮峟弇弇怷彖帢 弇帠怷彖 廒廔 廔棒 帤庣峸帠庢庣彖 庥帢庛巹帢帢庣. (p. 29, 17) 廒彖 帤廔 彃 帤庣庢帠庰彃庛帢庣 廔 峎帠弮帢帢... (p. 30, 19) 廒彖 帤廔 彃 庣怷彃羊庛帢庣... 廒徆怷弮帢庣 帤廔 廒廔 彃僇 庥帢弇怷弮峟彖彖 廒彖峟彖彖 巹庰彖... 庣彃 帤廔 彖庰彖庰弮庢弮峟彖彖 怷彖, 庰廒棲 庰 廔 彄僇割樁 庥帢廔 廔 廒缶裕諫 庥帢廔 廔 峎庛怷, 廔 弮廔統 廒庥 怷彃 峎帠弮帢怷 怷廔帤庰彖廔裒 庰彃怷彖 庰廔庰彃彖 庰 庥帢廔 廒徆庰庣庰彃彖 帤彖帢帢庣 巹帢. 庥帢廔 帠廔區 怷彃 庰廒匿磁怷 廒庣怷 廔 廒彖廔棲 庰廒匿睡救廔棲 庥帢廔 怷彃 帢帢帤庰巹帠弮帢怷 帤廔 峎 庰 庢弮庰彃帢... 庰廒區 庰庥弮庢巹彖 帤徆帢彖 廒帠帢帠庰彃彖 帤彖帢廔樞帢怷... (p. 32, 1) 庥廒彖 怷彃 廒庣弇帠怷庣 帤廔 廔 弮廔統 廒彖帢庥庰帢弇帢庣庣庥廔裕 彃僇 彃用煎裕倀誕彖 弮峟怷... 廔 帤廔 帢庛庢庣庥廔裕 廒庥庰彃彖怷, 廒彖 彄 帢峎庥弇庢巹 庰 庥帢廔 廒弇庰怷 庥帢廔 帤峟庢庣... 怷彃 怷峸庥怷彖怷 廒彖帤庰庰峟 廒怷帤巹帤庣彖.
Singula (supra non relata), quae Dionysius de prooemii officiis, de narratione instituenda, de argumentis, de epilogis exponit, posterioribus admodum sunt decantata (de traditione apud posteriores continua Peters 24 sq). Velim etiam conferas cum iis, quae de prooemio Dionysius dicit, Demosthenis verba in Timocr. (24) 4: 庰廒區庛帢庣彖 弮廔統 怷廔彖 怷廒 怷弇弇怷廔 彃僇 峎庰庣彖 庣 怷帢庣怷弮峟彖彖 彃僇 庥怷庣彖彃僇 弇峟帠庰庣彖, 廔＋ 帢彃羊帢 廔弮彃彖 怷帤帢庣帢峎 廒庣彖 庥帢廔 弮峎弇庣帢 廒徆庣怷彖 怷峟庰庣彖 怷怷庣, 廔廔紮 廔形 廒彖 帢廔怷廔 帠峎彖庣 怷庣怷弮庰彖怷庣 怷廔磁 弇帠怷. Talia praecepta, 廒匿救庰弮帢帢 庥帢廔 庥怷庣彖峎 quae audiunt Arist怷teli (rhet. 1416 a 24), ut sunt pervetusta, ita fortasse in Isocratis schola primum omnibus numeris constituta, id quod viri docti imprimis ex eo consensu concluserunt, qui est inter Dionysium, Aristotelem, Amaximenem, Anonymum Segueri (Graeveni Cornutum). Cf. Marx 315 sq., Wendland 39 sq., Peters 22 sq., Suess 193 sq. Theodectae, Isocratis discipulo, haec adscripsit F. Solmsen (Herm. 67, 144 sq.), quod vix ita dici potest. 庛庰庣彖 atque 庰廔弮峎庛庰庣帢彖 a prooemio separasse videntur Isocratei (Peters 29).
30. Syrianus in Hermog. de id. I p. 93, 22 R. (Sh. 6a): 廒彖 帠廔區 帢彃 庥帢帢峎庰庣 峎 庰 怷廒匿睡菲帢 彖庣彃僇樁舒 庥帢巹 廔 彃僇 廒彖帢彖巹彖 帤庣帢帣峎弇弇怷弮庰彖, 廔裒 廔 怷廒匿睡菲怷彖 弮峟怷彖 廒帠帢庤弮庰彖怷庣 廔區 庥帢帢峎庰庣, 廔＋ 廒裒怷庥峎庢 廒帤巹帤帢徆庰彖.
Indidem Maximus Planudes et Anon. in Hermog. W V 551, 10 sq.
31. Syrianus in Hermog. de id. I p. 25, 1 R.: 庥帢廔 帠廔區 廒裒怷庥峎庢 廒彖 彃 彃用煙怷庣庥彃 峟彖彃 帤庣帤峎庥彖, 廔 廔 帤庣庢帠庰彃庛帢庣, 庢巹 帤庣庢帠庢峟怷彖 帤廔 庰 彄僇割樁 庥帢廔 廔 廔 怷彃 峎帠弮帢怷 庥帢廔 廔 弮庰廔 廔 彄僇割樁 庥帢廔 廔區 帤庣帢彖怷巹帢, 帢廒煙 廒庥峎庰怷 彃僇 廒帠彖庣庤怷弮峟彖彖 廒帢徆庰 帤庰 庣.
Haec Arstot. tangit rhet. 1417 a 28. 36 (Marx 321).
32. Idem in Hermog. II 65, 3 R. (Sh. 5): 庥帢廔 帠廔區 廒裒怷庥峎庢 廒彖 彃 峟彖彃 庢巹彖, 廔＋ 廒彖 彃 帤庣庢帠峸庰庣 弇庰庥峟怷彖 庰 彄僇割樁 庥帢廔 廔 廔 怷彃 峎帠弮帢怷 庥帢廔 廔 弮庰廔 廔 彄僇割樁 庥帢廔 廔區 帤庣帢彖怷巹帢, 帢廒煙 廒庥峎庰怷 彃僇 廒帠彖庣庤怷弮峟彖彖 弮庰彖怷 帤庰 庣 峟帢庰彖.
33. Idem ibid. II, p. 170, 23 (Sh. 6): 弮峎弇庣帢 帤廔 廔 帢宎 廒裒怷庥峎怷 庰廔 廒彖 庰廒區庢弮峟彖怷彖 廒彖 彃 峟彖彃 弮彖庢弮怷彖庰峟怷彖 廔＋ 庰庣庥怷庢峟怷彖 廒彖 彃 庥帢帢峎庰庣 庰 彄僇割樁 庥帢廔 廔 廔 怷彃 峎帠弮帢怷 庥帢廔 廔 弮庰廔 廔 彄僇割樁 庥帢廔 廔區 帤庣帢彖怷巹帢, 帢廒煙 廒庥峎庰怷 彃僇 廒帠彖庣庤怷弮峟彖彖 帤庰 庣 峟帢庰彖 廒 弮峟弇弇庰庣 峎庰庣彖, 庥帢廔 怷彖 怷彃 弮帣帢弇弇怷弮峟彖怷庣 廒﹡澄彖 庢峟怷彖.
Non sibi constat Syrianus, sed tertiam formam laudat Sopater W IV 712, 23, secundam Anon. W VII 721, 17, primam alter Anonymus W VII 917, 16, omnes ex Syriano. Putes tamen 庥帢峎帢庣彖 re vera narrationem ab Isocrateis esse dictam. Ad rem (庰廔 帤庣帢彖怷巹帢) v. etiam Pl繹bst p. 32sq.
34. Quint. inst. 4, 2, 31 (Sh. 14. 15): (de narrati怷ne) eam plerique scriptores maximeque qui sunt ab Isocrate volunt esse lucidam, brevem, veri similem. neque enim refert, an pro lucida perspicuam, pro veri simili probabilem credibilemve dicamus.
I. e. 帢彃, 彖怷弮怷彖, 庣庛帢彖峸彖. Confer Anon. rhet. l. p. 365, 6 H. (Graeveni Cornutus est): 彃 帤庣庢帠峸庰 廔區 廒庰峎 帢弮庰彖 峸彖 庰 彖怷弮巹帢彖 庥帢廔 廔棒 帢峸彖庰庣帢彖 庥帢廔 廔棒 庣庛帢彖庢帢, Rufi rhet. p. 402, 14 H., Dion. de Lysia p. 30, 2 Us.-R., qui 廒裒怷庥峎庰庣 庰 庥帢廔 怷彃 庥帢宎 廒庥庰彃彖怷彖 廔裕 廒彖帤帢 庥怷弮怷弮峟彖怷庣 廒峟庥怷彖帢 se tradere dicit ibid. p. 27, 13 (v. supra 29). Isocratem aperte sequitur Anaximenes 30 p. 72, 1 H.: 帤庰彃 怷彖 廒庥帢怷彖 怷庣庰彃彖 帣帢峟 庥帢廔 帢彃剿 庥帢廔 弮廔 廒巹 庥弇. De doctrinae propagatione v. Spengel ad Anaximenem p. 214 sq. Schol. ABT Il. E 9. Isocratem impugnat Aristot. rhet. 1416 b 30, quod notat Quintilianus loco supra exhibito addens: eadem nobis placet divisio, quamquam et Aristoteles ab Isocrate parte in una dissenserit, praeceptum brevitatis irridens. V. B XXII 6, Isocratis ipsius 21, 2. 7, 19. 19, 4. Ceterum cf. Marx p. 320 sq. Wendland 39 sq. Peters 57 sq.
35. Georgius Pletho W VI 587, 9 (Spengel Aristot. Rhet. II 360): 帢廒 帤廔 彃 廒弮庢彖庰巹帢 怷彃 弇帠怷 峟帢庰 廒庰帢巹, 弮彄僇銜銜諺 帤廔 怷彃 帤庣帤帢庥帢弇庣庥怷彃 庥帢廔 廒救怷庣庥怷彃, 庥帢庛庰峸庥帢庣彖 帢廒舒棒肅 帢峸彖庰庣帢, 彖怷弮巹帢, 庣庛帢彖庢, 弮庰帠帢弇怷峟庰庣帢, 廔＋ 廒裒怷庥峎庰庣 庥帢廔 廒弮庰帤怷庥弇庰彃, 庣怷彖巹彃, 峖庣弇怷峎彃, 廒裕敖樁統銜耆彃 庥帢廔 彄剿庣 帢弇帢庣怷彃 庥帢廔 怷彃 怷峟怷庣 彃僇 彖峟彖 帤怷庥庰彃.
Cf. B XXII 6. Tribus Isocratis virtutibus 廔 廒﹡棲 addit Anon. Seg. p. 369, 19 H, sicut Dionysius de Lysia p. 30, 3 U.-R., is quidem, postquam antea de Isocrate eiusque asseclis locutus est. Cf. de Demosth. p. 167, 1.
36. Theon Progymn. Rhet. Gr. II p. 92, 24 Sp.: 帤庣峸帠庢庣彖 帤廔 帤庣庢帠峸庰庣 弮弇峟庥庰庣彖 廒巹彖, 廔帢彖 帤怷 帤庣庢帠峸庰庣 廒 庥帢廔 弇庰巹怷 廒弮帢 帤庣庢帠庰彃庛帢庣 廒庣庰庣彃僇樁舒. 怷彃羊怷 帤廔 弮峎弇帢 廒庰峸帤庰帢彖 怷廒 廒廔 廒裒怷庥峎怷 庥帢廔 帢廔廔裒 廔 廒裒怷庥峎庢 廒彖 彃 帢彖庢帠庣庥彃 怷廔. (54) 廒缶銜裕諺 怷廒 庛宎 廒戕帢庥弇峟怷 帢彃帤庰 庥帢廔 弮庣庥廔裕 廔 怷彖 廒帤帢怷 廔 峇帢弇帢怷彃, 帣帢庣弇庰廔磁 廔卅 廒帠怷, 怷廔怷 弮廔統 廒庥 彃 帢庰巹帢 彃 廒廔 峸帣帢 帤庰帤庢庥廔樞 庥帢廔 廔 廒徆彃. 庥帢廔 峎弇庣彖 (68) 廒庣 帠廔區 帢庰庣彖彃 怷廔庢 彃 廒弇弇峎帤怷 廒缶銜裕諺 庰廒區 廔棒 帢彖 廒﹡澄蕊彖 彄煎睡舜 弮廔統 弮庰廔 廔弮弇怷 怷彃 怷庰庣帤彃僇諄諫, 峉庥庛帢庣 帤廔 弮庰廔 廒弮帢庤彖彖 彃僇 廒庰 庛帠帢峟彖 怷廔 庥帢廔 廔裕 帢廔廔裕 彖怷彖 庥帢廔 廔 廒徆彃. Aliud est praeceptum atque ea, quae antecedunt.
37. Quint. inst. 3, 4, 11 (Sh. 12): Isocrates in 怷mni genere inesse laudem ac vituperationem existimavit.
Scil. proprium genus laudationum non agnovit, cf. 庰廔 廒彖庣帤. (15) 45 sq.
38. Ioannes Sic. Schol. 庰廒區 廒裕棒菲蕊彖 帣 VI 478, 23 W: 彃剿怷 廒裒怷庥峎庢 廒彖庰峟庣庰彖, 帠峎帢 廒帠庥弮庣帢.
Cf. Maximus Plan. V 554, 4 W, Diogenes Laert. 2, 55.
39. Quint. inst. 3, 5, 18 (Sh. 13): Isocrates autem causam esse ait quaestionem finitam civilem aut rem controversam in personarum finitarum complexu.
Socrates cod. Ambrosianus. Thiele, Herm. 27, 13 sq.
40. Catalogus librorum bibliothecae rhetoris alicuius Rhodi repertus (Gn怷mon II 196): 庥帢帢帤怷弮廔 (Isocratis) 彃[因 帤庣帢庣帣彃[].
Vitae Isocrateae auctor (Or. Att. II 5 a 24, Westermann, Biogr. gr. 257, 26): 庰廒 帤峟 庣彖庰 廒庰庣峎帠怷庣彖 廒弇弇怷 庣彖廔區 弇帠怷 廔＋ 廔彖帢 帢廔怷彃, 怷廔 怷帤庰庥峟怷彖 廒庥庰巹彖怷 帢廔 怷廔磁 庰怷弮峟彖怷. Sequitur spuriorum catalogus, ultimus titulus est 庥帢帢帤怷弮廔 怷庣彃僇.