Service Contracts
Date
November 25, 1999
Revision Date
February 1, 2007 - Appendix A
July 29, 2013 - Appendices B & H
Number
AD 3.13
Revision No.
In each of the areas of ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV’s three main missions - teaching, research and service - there are opportunities to enter into contractual relationships with external governmental, commercial, and other non-governmental entities, where these relationships are consistent with the goals and standards of the University. These have the potential to provide revenue to the University, but also expose the University to liability. In all cases, it is essential that there be clear policy in place to guide the formation of such relationships, the use of University resources and the distribution within the University of the proceeds. This will ensure proper recognition of the resources committed by the University and avoidance of unnecessary liability, conflict-of-interest and inappropriate competition with the private sector.
2.0 Principles
This Policy applies to all contractual relationships that commit the University to provide services other than research; it does not apply to non-disclosure agreements or material transfer agreements. These services include, but are not limited to analytical services and administrative services. It includes contracts that involve joint ventures with other organizations to provide such services. It does not include credit or non-credit teaching services or conferences organized through ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV Conference Services. Policy R10.01 governs research contracts and grants.
The University is the only legal entity that has the ability to enter into contractual relationships with other legal entities to provide services that involve its resources. Individuals, Departments, Faculties, Institutes and Centres do not have that ability, although specific administrators within them may be delegated the authority by the Board of Governors to conclude such relationships on behalf of the University, if these are in compliance with relevant Board Policies including this one. In addition, wholly-owned subsidiaries of the University like SF Univentures may enter into contractual relationships that may involve use of the University name and/or trademarks, with the authorization of appropriate University administrators.
Coordination of the provision of services is required in order to prevent duplication and other inefficiencies. It is the responsibility of the person with the authority to conclude a contract to ensure that adequate consultation has occurred within the University.
Contracts for secret work are strictly forbidden and will under no circumstances be approved for administration by the University.
Service contracts must contain budgets that recognize all the direct and indirect costs of performing the work and all sources of income.
This Policy applies to those activities which involve use of ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV facilities, resources, or services and does not apply to services, research or other activities performed by University employees under personal contract, wholly outside the University. (see Policy A30.04 - "Disclosure and Approval of Outside Activities").
3.0 Definitions
Contract - a legally enforceable agreement which may include conditions setting forth specific terms governing the conduct, direction and scheduling of the tasks to be performed; designating ownership of proprietary rights to the results; laying out the financial regimen to be followed; and other restrictions required by the Sponsor. There is the normal expectation of some deliverable(s) flowing to the Sponsor.
Sponsor - the external party that provides funds for the performance of services under a contract.
Principal - a person authorized to perform work under the contract, who is responsible for the project. The Principal must be an employee of the University whose term of appointment is expected to span the term of the contract.
University Resources - these include but are not limited to: office and laboratory space, teaching and research equipment, facilities and services such as the Library, University computing network and systems, the Animal Care Facility and the Instructional Media Centre.
International Activities - these include but are not limited to activities that involve provision of services outside Canada, or involve a partner organization outside of Canada, or involve provision of services to individuals and/or organizations from outside of Canada.
A proposal to enter into a service contract may be initiated by any employee of the University. Approvals to pursue the proposal further must be obtained from that person’s immediate supervisor and all his/her supervisors up to the level of the person with the authority to approve the final contract on behalf of the University. This authority is specified, with respect to the dollar amount of the contract, by the Signing Resolutions of the ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV Board of Governors. These are described in to this Policy and may be changed from time-to-time by action of the Board of Governors. In addition, when proposals include international activities, the proposal must be submitted to the ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV Senate Committee on International Activities (SCIA) for review and must receive the approval of the Vice-President, Academic. Refer to ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV Policy GP-23 - "University Policy on International Activities." Any disagreement over whether the work under the contract comprises research or service will be resolved jointly by the Vice-President, Academic and the Vice-President, Research; if this is not possible, the question will be referred for resolution to the President.
In order to receive final approval, the final form of a service contract must receive the approvals of all the persons mentioned in the preceding paragraph. to this Policy has a link to the Final Approval Form. To receive final approval, it must normally satisfy all the following criteria:
- There must be a clear statement of the work to be performed, including deliverables and the schedule on which these must be provided;
- There must be an itemized budget containing all sources of income for the project and all areas of expenditure. Explicit recognition of all the costs, both direct and indirect, must be included under "expenses." In specific cases, for specific reasons, some of these costs may be contributed by the University; in these cases, specific recognition of such contributions must be included under "income;" sample budgets are available through the office of the Vice-President, Academic;
- There must be a schedule of payments, including the criteria for payment (e.g. milestones; reports) and means of initiating payment (e.g. prepayment, invoices);
- There must be a clear description of reporting requirements, both financial and with respect to the performance of the work, which includes specification of the person or unit responsible for generating and transmitting the reports - if Financial Services would be required to generate or file reports, their approval of the terms of the contract must be obtained;
- There must be provision in the contract for recognition of the indirect costs (overhead costs) of providing the services indicated at rates that are consistent with those given below under Guidelines;
- There must be specification of the term of the contract and the period during which the work will be performed - these may differ;
- There must be provision for early termination of the contract that clearly specifies the conditions under which this may occur and the consequences for all parties;
- There must be provision for modifications to be made to the contract, preferably without reconsideration of the entire contract;
- Normally persons employed under the contract will be University employees. In exceptional circumstances, other arrangements may be appropriate. To determine the appropriate procedures to follow, the Principal should contact Human Resources prior to signing of the proposed contract. For persons employed under contract as employees of the Principal, refer to Appendices C and D to this Policy for sample employment letters and Appendix E for a statement of the responsibilities and obligations of the Principal as an employer;
- There must be provision for the disposition of intellectual property (IP) created in the course of performing the contract;
- There must be provision for the handling of any pre-existing IP provided by the University and/or Sponsor during the course of performing the contract;
- There must be provision for monitoring the performance under the contract, both on the part of the Principal and on the part of the Sponsor;
- The contract must not expose the University to unacceptable levels of risk or liability, including risk of non-payment for services rendered;
- The contract must be consistent with all pertinent external legislation (e.g. taxation and Freedom of Information/Protection of Privacy) and internal agreements (e.g. agreements between the University and its employee groups);
- The contract must be consistent with all other relevant University Policies including but not limited to those on Conflict of Interest, Faculty Responsibilities, Freedom of Information/Protection of Privacy, Animal Care, Research Involving Human Subjects, Radiological Safety, Biosafety, Diving Safety, Intellectual Property (patent and copyright), International Activities, and the use of the University’s Trade-Marks. Note that several of the above-mentioned Policies mandate review and prior approval by other University Committees;
- In cases where joint ventures are proposed, there are the additional requirements for: a) a business plan, b) staffing plans, and c) a clear description of equity contributions by the University, if any, and their size and source. In addition, there must be indication that consultation has occurred adequate to assure that there is no duplication of effort within the University and an indication of the schedule on which approvals of Senate and the Board of Governors would be sought (if required) or a statement to the effect that such approvals are not required;
- Contracts involving international activities must contain an explicit agreement by the signatories to comply with the Policy on International Activities. The Office of International Cooperation should be consulted on the appropriate procedures to follow;
- Under the contract, all cheques for payments received under the contract must be forwarded, along with appropriate backup identifying the contract and account number, to Financial Services for deposit.
- provision of any University resources, including equipment and space; approval of these agreements must be given by the parties responsible for the specific resources; and
- distribution within the University of funds or other assets received by the University, above the direct and indirect costs of performing the work.
Contracts involving Research Centres and Institutes established under ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV Policy R40.01 must receive approval of their Administrative Officer in addition to the other persons described in the first paragraph of this section.
A checklist of contract terms and conditions is provided in to this Policy for the guidance of persons proposing contracts.
Work under a proposed contract must not commence until the contract receives final approval by the sponsor and by the University, as described above. The only exception to this is when an explicit, firm commitment to cover all costs and liabilities associated with an earlier start is made by the person with the authority to approve the final contract on behalf of the University, as described in the first paragraph of this section. In such a case, a copy of the current draft contract, including budget, reporting and billing requirements, the account to which expenses will be charged if the contract is not approved ("back-up account") and a Pre-Approval Financial Guarantee Form (copy attached as ) must be sent to Financial Services for review. If the draft contract appears to contain reasonable financial terms, Financial Services will set up a new account and expenses may be charged to that account. This preliminary approval will not imply approval of the terms of the final form of the contract. Financial Services may set a time limit within which the contract must be finalized. Note that the final contract may contain a date of commitment which could restrict the period within which expenses can be incurred. In this case, the contract account may not normally be charged for work done prior to the start date and the back-up account would be charged any such expenses.
5.0 Contract Terms
Direct costs include the value of the time of ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV employees and/or the cost of replacing these employees, as appropriate. The budget of the contract should include explicit reference to these costs and to all other direct costs such as space rental, provision of managerial services, equipment maintenance and materials and supplies.
Normally, overhead rates will be set at 40% of total direct costs for on-campus work and at 20% of total direct costs for off-campus work. Overhead on contracts that involve a combination of on-campus and off-campus work will be set at a rate that reflects their relative proportions. Direct costs include the full value of the time of ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV employees (salary and benefits) and/or the full cost of replacing these employees, as appropriate.
Overhead may be reduced from the levels indicated above in consideration of other tangible benefits accruing to the University such as equity-holding or revenue-sharing agreements, or intangible benefits such as increased community profile. As noted above, such reduction in overhead comprises a contribution by the University and should be so recognized under both the revenue and cost sections of the contract budget.
The person with authority to approve the service contract on behalf of the University has the authority to negotiate with the external agency the terms of the contract, including payment schedules, reporting schedules and the amount of overhead charged. Authority to negotiate (but not to approve the contract) may be delegated. Unless other arrangements are made in advance with the responsible Vice-President, that person, in approving a contract on behalf of the University, assumes full financial responsibility through his/her office for assuring that overhead payments are adequate to cover the indirect costs, and for the University’s liabilities from such factors as patent or copyright infringement and non-performance - including non-payment - on the part of the external agency. For this reason, it is required that all contracts be vetted by Financial Services prior to conclusion.
In cases where different units within the University are capable of providing the same or similar services, it is the responsibility of the person with the authority to approve a contract to make certain that adequate consultation has occurred within the University to ensure that the provision of the services under the contract is as efficient as reasonably possible and that duplication of effort is minimized.
With the exception of contracts that have a University-wide impact, all overheads realized from service contracts normally will be divided equally between General University Revenue and the initiating Faculty or equivalent unit; exceptions to this method of division require approval of the President. Contracts that have a University-wide impact will be reviewed by the Vice-President, Academic and the Vice-President, Finance and Administrative Services to determine the disposition of overheads, prior to final approval of the contract.
In cases of contracts involving foreign or other unusual settings, contract terms should take into account the specific cultures or modes of conducting business in those settings. Because there are additional costs normally associated with identifying, developing and delivering international activities, overhead rates are expected to be higher for international service contracts than for domestic ones. Guidelines for the financial conduct of international service contracts are contained in to this Policy.
Contracts for secret work will not be approved for administration by the University. Results of all work undertaken in the University shall be fully publishable at the discretion of the Principal, subject to the qualification that a Sponsor may be given the right under the terms of a contract to publish research results of the work or approve such publication in advance. However, the Principal shall be completely free to publish after a maximum of 12 months from termination of the project or submission of the final report, whichever is later.
6.0 Payments to University Employees
Payments to Principals who are continuing University employees from contract funds are governed by Policy AD 3-11 "Employee/Independent Contractor Policy." Such payments normally will be withheld until the contract is successfully completed, all terms fulfilled and all payments received from the Sponsor. In the case of long-term contracts, partial payments may be made prior to completion of the contract at the discretion of the Department Chair and Faculty Dean (or equivalents for other employees).
Copies of all contracts must be lodged with the responsible Vice-President and with Financial Services immediately on signing of the contract. In addition, for contracts involving international activities, a copy must be provided to the Office of International Cooperation.
8.0 Appendices
The appendices to this policy comprise guidance to persons proposing service contracts and may be altered by the responsible Vice-President without the necessity of approval by the Board of Governors of ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV.
9.0 Interpretation
Questions of interpretation and application of this Policy or its procedures shall be referred to the President, whose decision shall be final.
Level of Authorization required to Approve Service Contracts
The level of authorization required to approve service contracts on behalf of the University is determined under the ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV Board of Governors Signing Resolutions, approved by the Board on April 15, 1993 and most recently amended by the Board on February 1, 2007. Full documentation is available from the Secretary to the Board; a brief synopsis may be located in the following document (in pdf format).
In cases where the work under a service contract is to be performed by a unit that does not report to the Vice-President, Academic, refer to the Board of Governors Signing Resolutions (B10.11) for the appropriate level of authorization to approve the contract.Checklist for Service Contracts (see Service Agreement Template at Appendix H)
- Identify parties in the legal agreement: ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV & Funding Source.
- Identify term of contract - start date and end date.
- Review budget for:
- amount to be paid by funding agency;
- method of calculation;
- overhead;
- use of funds (restrictions on line items vs. bottom line budget control); GST implications;
- carry-forward provisions;
- payment, if any, to Principal;
- payment to sub-contractor(s), if any;
- operating fund budget implications, if any.
- Review ownership of fixed assets purchased under the contract.
- Review payment arrangements:
- installments;
- billing requirements;
- payment schedule (timing and frequency);
- whether payment is contingent on deliverables, financial reports and/or progress reports;
- acknowledgement of receipt of funds;
- holdbacks;
- disposition of any unspent balance.
- installments;
- Review reporting requirements:
- responsibility for reporting;
- timing and frequency of reporting;
- degree of detail and work involved (efforts should be concentrated on reducing complex reporting; any requirement to submit copies of supporting invoices and vouchers should be strongly resisted).
- responsibility for reporting;
- Review intellectual property (IP) requirements:
- Confidentiality and/or restrictions on publication (secret work is not permitted);
- Ownership of resultant IP.
- Confidentiality and/or restrictions on publication (secret work is not permitted);
- Review audit requirements:
- length of time that documents are required to be kept after completion of contract imposition of other particular auditing requirements.
- Review responsibility of reporting on in-kind contributions.
- Evaluate financial risk factors:
- type of contract (e.g. sub-contract that may pose liability after termination of main contract);
- financial stability (history and current) of the company;
- experience with the company or funding agency by the University and other organizations.
- type of contract (e.g. sub-contract that may pose liability after termination of main contract);
- Review termination clause:
- right of the University to terminate the contract;
- right to terminate with reimbursement of all expenses incurred.
- right of the University to terminate the contract;
- Review potential for limiting the University’s liability.
- Review potential conflicts of interest (e.g. Principal also has an interest in the contracting party).
- Completion of the Final Approval Form - Appendix H to this Policy — including provision of a complete copy of the final version of the contract.
Sample Employment Letter
Short-Term Service Contract Personnel
For a sample PDF employment letter for Short-Term Service Contract Personnel click here.
If you do not have Adobe Acrobat reader .
Sample of Employment Letter
Long-Term Service Contract Personnel
For a sample PDF employment letter for Long-Term Service Contract Personnel click here.
If you do not have Adobe Acrobat reader .
Statements of Responsibilities
Responsibilities of the Principal Toward Persons Funded Through a Service Contract (Herein called "Contract Employees"),
As Employees of the Principal
With respect to the employment of contract employees, Principals shall exercise the following responsibilities:
- The Principal shall determine whether or not the services of a contract employee are required.
- The Principal shall determine whether or not sufficient service contract funds are available to permit the payment of wages and benefits to a contract employee.
- The Principal shall classify the contract employee's position and rate of reimbursement in accordance with the terms established in the service contract. Where no such terms are stipulated, the Principal is encouraged to ensure that contract employees receive reimbursement and benefits appropriate to the tasks assigned.
- Subject to any conditions established by the funding agency, the Principal shall exercise sole discretion over the decision to hire a contract employee.
- The Principal shall forward a copy of the contract employee's appointment letter to the appropriate Academic Department, to Human Resources, and to the Financial Services, Specific Purpose Section. The Principal shall also forward a completed form FPP4 (Appointment Form, Research Service contracts) to the Financial Services, Specific Purpose Section. Such a requirement is necessary in order to enable the University to perform administrative and custodial services on the Principal's behalf.
- It shall be the Principal's responsibility to authorize payment of contract employee wages from the service contract funds.
- Subject to any limits established by the service contract or contract, the Principal's decision shall be final regarding a contract employee's pay scale adjustment, benefits, wage increase or merit increase.
- The Principal shall comply with all statutory obligations of the employer, including the obligation to provide statutory benefits.
- Together with the contract employee, the Principal shall determine whether or not a contract employee shall be given access to a non-statutory benefits program administered on behalf of the Principal by the University. A decision to provide access shall be subject to the condition that the employer's share of the optional benefits program is available, and shall be paid from service contract funds.
- The Principal shall exercise sole control and direction over the assignment of duties and the work performed by a contract employee.
- The Principal shall exercise sole discretion over the decision to terminate the employment of a contract employee.
Statement of Responsibilities of the University
With respect to Principals employing personnel who are engaged under service contracts or contracts, the University shall exercise the following responsibilities:
- The University shall provide custodial and administrative services for the receipt and disbursement of service contract funds.
- Upon request, Human Resources shall assist Principals to determine appropriate wage scales for contract employees, and will provide recruitment, interviewing, and candidate selection services. Human Resources shall also assist Principals by making available sample Appointment Letters.
- On Principal's behalf, the University shall maintain employment records for contract employees.
- The University shall advise Principals regarding their statutory obligations as employers.
- With respect to both statutory and non-statutory employee benefits, the Principal may consult with Human Resources and Financial Services.
- Upon request from the Principal, and with the agreement of the contract employees, the University shall provide access to a non-statutory benefits program, subject to the condition that the employer's share of the optional benefits program is paid from service contract funds.
Appendix F
Pre-Approval Financial Guarantee Form
Guarantee of costs and liabilities preceding final contract approval on service contracts (non-research) as per policy AD3-13.
To request a project number to be assigned for a contract prior to the final approval of that contract, this form is to be submitted to the Special Purpose Fund section in Financial Services along with a copy of the draft contract. The draft contract should include information on the contract budget, reporting and billing requirements. Note that the final contract may contain a date of commitment which could restrict the period within which expenses can be incurred. In this case, the contract account may not normally be charged for work done prior to the start date and the backup account would be charged any such expenses.
In regard to the following contract,
SPONSOR _______________________________________
PRINCIPAL _______________________________________
EXPECTED CONTRACT AMOUNT $ _____________________________________
I hereby authorize any costs or liabilities incurred with respect to the above contract to be charged to the account ___-_____________-_______ in the event that the contract is not approved and signed on or before _____________________________ or that the pre-contract costs or liabilities are deemed to be ineligible for reimbursement under the final contract.
These pre-contract costs or liabilities are not to exceed $________________________.
Guarantor Name _____________________ Position______________________
_________________________________________
Signature
_______________________________________
Date
Guidelines for the Financial Conduct of International Service Contracts
In general, the procedures and contract terms detailed in Policy AD 3-13 are appropriate and applicable to international as well as domestic activities. However, there are certain characteristics of international activities, including their cost, that require some special arrangements.
While the following guidelines apply to international activities, it is also recognized that exceptions should be considered on their merit.
Overhead Recovery
Unless otherwise established by the client, donor, or funding agency, and agreed to by the University, recovery of indirect or overhead costs shall be equivalent to at least 50 percent of total personnel costs (i.e. actual salaries plus benefits).
Fifty percent of recoveries for indirect costs shall be payable to General University Requirements (GUR), with the remaining 50 percent returned to the Dean of the Faculty or unit in which the initiative is located. In cases where the initiating unit does not report to a Dean, the division of indirect cost recoveries will be negotiated with the Vice-President, Finance and Administration.
When faculty or staff participate in projects fully funded by external sources, their Faculty or home unit shall receive a compensatory financial incentive amounting to no less than full salary replacement. Compensation for the cost of benefits shall be payable to GUR.
Special Cases
Without limiting the general applicability of the above, there are a number of special cases that fall outside conventional project-based activities that require special incentive arrangements. These include education and training programs that derive their revenues exclusively from fee-based services and the export of credit and non-credit instruction or courseware.
Fee-Based Services
- All services that generate their principal revenues from client fees shall be required to recapture their own direct costs, including contract staff salaries and benefits, communications, administration, and facilities rental.
- The University shall be compensated for the indirect costs of administering financial, personnel, and associated services at a rate to be determined through negotiation with the Vice-President, Finance and Administration.
- "Profits," defined in this instance as revenues remaining after deductions for direct and indirect costs are made, shall normally be divided one-third to GUR and two-thirds to the Dean of the unit in which the initiative is housed or, in the absence of a reporting relationship to a Dean, to the Vice-President, Finance and Administration, who shall negotiate its distribution. The Vice-President, Academic has the sole authority to approve deviations from this distribution.
- Where fee-based services are provided by one unit within the University to support projects or programs initiated elsewhere in the institution, the unit providing the training shall receive the full amount of the training fees paid by the client for that particular program or service.
- No "finder’s fee" is to be charged for identifying opportunities taken up by another unit within the University.
International Sale of Distance Education Courses
Revenues from the international sale of distance education courses shall be allocated in two ways:
- An amount consistent with the University Copyright Policy (R30.01) will be paid to the course creator.
- The remaining revenues shall be applied to new program and course development in distance education, and to course re-development and revision.
Individuals Employed to Deliver International Services
- No individual, on contract or engaged through direct employment with the University, shall normally receive financial benefit from participation in the University’s international activities beyond their negotiated levels of remuneration.
- Exceptions may be permitted for faculty at the discretion of the unit head and the Faculty Dean, and all such exceptions shall be consistent with University policy AD 3-11, Employee/Independent Contractor Policy.
- Exceptions for staff or consultants shall require the same approvals as in the case of faculty except where there is no reporting relationship to a Dean. In such cases, approval from the Vice-President, Finance and Administration, shall be required.
- Activities delivered in the name of ¶¡ÏãÔ°AV are not to be structured in such a way that substantive components are contracted separately to individuals (or firms), with the University having little or no effective control over quality of work, and with a resulting financial return to the University that is insufficient relative to the responsibilities and risk borne by the University.